ngin - Norfolk Genetic Information Network

13 March 2003


This article is from the same journalist and paper that at the end of January reported the Royal Society's view that the collapse in public confidence in scientists like themselves was entirely the fault of media and fraud. That article, and the accompanying editorial, categorised Arpad Pusztai's research as "fraud" as well as providing an almost completely fabricated account of it!

There is no indication here as to whether the Danish research referred to, which purports to find benefits for biodiversity from the growing of GM beet, looked at yield - a critical factor in terms of whether farmers are going to spray GM crops "precisely according to the instructions from the manufacturer". If those instructions are complex, or are likely to penalise yield, then many farmers in non-trial situations are likely to use the total herbicide to achieve weed free fields, rather than to encourage weeds. Farmers are, after all, hardly known for their love of weeds or reduced yields!  for more on this:

No research, it seems, is being done into the real probability of farmers following such instructions outside of trial situations contrived to achieve the desired results rather than reflect real-world farming practices.


Report finds GM crops are good for environment

By Charles Arthur Technology Editor
The Independent
13 March 2003

Genetically-modified crops might be better for the environment than the unmodified form, allowing insects and spiders to flourish around their edges and providing more food for birds, according to new research.

The finding could hint at the results that will emerge from the farm-scale trials of GM crops now being carried out in Britain. Those will end this summer and be used by the Government to decide whether to allow commercial planting of GM crops, in which a key consideration is their effect on surrounding plant and animal life.

Tests at Denmark's National Environmental Research Institute discovered that when GM sugar beet was used precisely according to the instructions from the manufacturer, Monsanto, the plots had twice as many weeds compared with those planted with conventional beet. Beate Strandberg, who led the research, told New Scientist magazine that the GM plots also had more animal life than the conventional ones.

She thinks that the results from her tests will foreshadow those from the UK's farm-scale trials. Research at the Broom's Barn Experimental Station in Suffolk found earlier this year that if less herbicide is used than the manufacturers recommend, then the wildlife does even better. Dr Strandberg said that this confirmed her own work, which found that holding back on the use of weedkiller produced 10 times more weeds, and twice as many insects, but did not reduce the beet yield. "We have had very similar things going on," she said.

In the British farm-scale trials, which have been running for five years, the farmers have been told to follow the manufacturer's label instructions precisely when spraying GM crops so that the effect of widespread growing will be clearer.

Not all the findings were positive. The use of GM crops seemed to affect the balance of weeds species in fields: many died in late summer before they could produce seeds. The use of Monsanto's glyphosate weedkiller, to which the GM beet is resistant, could also help weeds such as dwarf nettles over those such as meadowgrass, and hence have "unpredictable" effects on the biodiversity within farm areas, the researchers said.

The Danish team has been working since 1990 on the effects of GM crops that are resistant to particular weedkillers. GM crops hold the promise of potentially higher yields, because their genetic modification means farmers can spray them with weedkiller without harming them; only the weeds die. But this has raised questions about the effect on animals and weeds that grow in the margins around the crops themselves.

Another issue that was not tackled directly in this study was whether the genes from the GM crops could pass to weeds. The British farm-scale trials will also investigate that, and try to rank its importance.

ngin bulletin archive